Insurance Claim? Or Insurance Maze?

-

Imagine this: You’ve paid your premiums religiously for five years. You treat your insurance policy like a safety net, tucked away for a rainy day. Then, the storm hits - a sudden hospitalization or a car accident. You file a claim, expecting immediate relief, but instead, you receive a cold, formal lettter. "Claim Rejected".

You aren't alone. In the financial year 2023-24, health insurance claim rejections in India surged by a staggering 19.10%, with insurers disallowing claims worth nearly ₹26,000 crore. For a college student or a young professional entering the workforce, understanding this "Claim Game" is no longer optional; it is a financial survival skill. 

This article breaks down why insurance claims become a maze, using real data from FY23-24 and 2025 outlooks, and what needs to be change for a fairer system. 

1. The Data: A grim picture of "Safety" 

Let’s look at the numbers first. The data reveals a widening gap between the promise of insurance coverage and the reality of settlement. 

  • The 11% Wall: According to IRDAI (Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India) data, insurers rejected 11% of all health insurance claims in 2023-24. Another 6% remained pending. This means nearly 1 in 5 policyholders faced immediate disappointment or long delays. 
  • The Rejection Surge: The value of rejected claims jumped from roughly ₹21,861 crore in FY23 to over ₹26,000 crore in FY24. This isn't just inflation; it's a systemic tightening of the purse strings by underwriters.
  • The Delay Factor: It’s not just about rejection; it's about the time value of money. Even in the motor insurance sector, global supply chain disruptions have stretched repair cycle times significantly. In India, finding genuine spare parts for newer models has led to settlement delays, leaving policyholders without vehicles for weeks while the claim status remains "In Process".

2. The "Fine Print" Trap: Why Claims Bleed? 

Why are so many claims dying on the table? The "difficulty" usually stems from three analytical categories: Non-Disclosure, Exclusions, and Administrative Friction.

    A. The "Pre-Existing" Landmine:

The single biggest reason for rejection remainds Non-Disclosure of Material Facts.

  • The Reality: If you fail to mention that you had asthma 10 years ago, and you claim for a lung infection today, the insurer can legally void your entire policy for "breach of trust." 
  • The Stat: Industry estimates suggest that nearly 25-30% of health claim rejections are purely due to non-disclosure of pre-existing diseases (PEDs). 
  • The Student Angle: When you buy your first bike or health cover online, clicking "No" on every medical question to save 5 minutes can cost you lakhs later. 

    B. The Waiting Period Game: 

Most people don't realize that insurance isn't instant.

  • Initial Waiting Period: usually 30 days for non-accidental hospitalization. 
  • Specific Illness Waiting Period: 2 years for common issues like stones, cataracts, or hernias. 
  • PED Waiting Period: 3 to 4 years for pre-existing conditions. 
  • Analysis: A significant portion of the 19% surge in rejections comes from policyholders claiming for "excluded" illnesses during these cooling-off periods. 

    C. "Reasonable and Customary" Charges: 

This is a vague clause that insurers love. If your hospital charges ₹10,000 for a bed but the insure believes the "market rate" in your city is ₹6,000, they will only pay ₹6,000. You pay the rest out of your pocket. This "partial settlement" is a massive, often under-reported difficulty that diminish the value of sum insured. 


3. Sector Spotlight: Health vs. Motor vs. Life 

The nature of difficulty varies significantly depending on what you are insuring.

Health Insurance: The Complexity Crisis 

Health claims are emotionally charged and administratively complex. 

  • Cashless vs. Reimbursement: While "Cashless" is marketed as seamless, yet only 60-65% of requests get authorized instantly. 
  • The Query Loop: Insurers often raise multiple queries "Send the X-ray film," "Provide the doctor's daily notes." Each query resets the clock, delaying discharge and forcing families to pay cash to leave the hospital, only to fight for reimbursement later. 


Motor Insurance: The Depreciation Hit 

In motor insurance, the difficulty isn't usually rejection (unless you were drunk driving or without a license), but valuation. 

Depreciation: Without a "Zero-Depreciation" add-on, you pay for the wear and tear of replaced parts. For a 5-year-old car, you might legally have to foot 50% of the cost of plastic and rubber parts.


Constructive Total Loss: If repair costs exceed 75% of the car's value, insurers may write it off. However, they pay the "Insured Declared Value" (IDV), which is often lower than the market price to replace your car. 


Life Insurance: The Hidden Claim Drama 

Life insurance claims appear straightforward, but families often struggle due to documentation and verification issues. 

  • Documentation Gaps: Claims are frequently delayed due to missing “Death Certificates”, incomplete hospital records, or errors in nominee details. 
  • Early-Claims Investigations: Early Claims (filed within the first two years of the policy) undergo intense investigation to ensure no medical history was hidden. 
  • Policy & Eligibility Issues: Mismatched income declaration, suicide exclusions, and policy lapses are also common reasons for delay.  


4. The Insurer's Defence: Why they are so strict? 

To be fair and analytical, we must look at the other side of the coin. Insurers aren't just being villains; they are fighting a war against Fraud and Inflation.

  • The Fraud Pandemic: Insurance fraud is a global issue. In India, "hospital-insurer cartels" often inflate bills for insured patients. To counter this, insurers have deployed AI detection systems. 
    • The Downside: These AI systems can trigger "false positives," flagging genuine claims as suspicious simply because the bill amount looks slightly higher than average algorithm prediction. 
  • Medical Inflation: With medical inflation in India hovering around 14% (double the general inflation), insurers are aggressively auditing claims to protect their solvency. They are rejecting "unnecessary" treatments (like prolonged ICU stays for minor ailments) to keep premiums affordable for everyone else. 


5. The Future: AI and The Human Disconnect

The future of claims is digital, but that brings new difficulties. 

  • Automated Rejection: Insurers are moving toward "No-Touch" claims processing. While this speeds up approval for simple cases, it makes it harder to argue your case if you have a complex, unique situation. You might find yourself arguing with a bot rather than a human claims manager. 
  • Cybersecurity Risks: As claims go digital, your medical data is at risk. The average cost of a data breach in 2024 was $4.88 million. A hack could freeze claim systems, leaving policyholders stranded, as seen in recent global IT outages. 

6. The Way Forward: What Needs to Change? 

While policyholders must be vigilant, the burden cannot be entirely on them. To fix the "Insurance Maze," the industry needs structural reforms: 

  • Standardization of Costs: The definition of "Reasonable and Customary Charges" needs a regulator-defined benchmark. Insurers cannot arbitrarily decide that a hospital is "too expensive" without a standard rate card to back it up. 
  • Simplified Disclosures: Proposal forms must be simplified. Often, non-disclosure is a result of confusion regarding medical terminology, not malicious intent. 
  • The 100% Cashless Mandate: The IRDAI's "Cashless Everywhere" initiative needs stricter enforcement to ensure hospitals don't turn away policyholders due to pricing disputes with insurers. 

7. Conclusion: How to Win the Game 

The "difficulty" in insurance claims is often a mix of information asymmetry (you don't know what they know) and bureaucratic friction. 

For the students reading this: Insurance is a contract, not a charity. The system is designed to pay what is contractually owed, not what you feel you deserve. 

  • Declare Everything: Even that minor surgery you had in 10th grade. 
  • Read the "Exclusions" First: Don't just look at what is covered; look at what isn't. 
  • Keep the Paper Trail: In the digital age, a missing physical discharge summary can still ruin your claim. Digitize and store every medical slip. 
  • Understand Waiting Periods & Limits: Know your policy’s waiting periods, sub-limits, and copays before hospitalization. These clauses decide how much of your bill the insurer will actually pay.

In the end, Insurance doesn’t fail people – Miscommunication does. 

Understanding the friction points, waiting periods, copays, and sub-limits is the only way to ensure that when you fall, the safety net holds.


References:


Blog by - Ashna Kushwaha and Shreya Prakash, M.Com Students 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Dominance of Western theories in Academia: A critical analysis

-
Image
  INTRODUCTION In academics, theories serve as the backbone for understanding and interpreting societal, political, economic, and cultural phenomena. However, a closer look at the dominant narratives in academia reveals a significant tilt toward western theories. For decades, western framework has shaped global academic discourse, often sidelining indigenous, non-western, or alternative perspectives. Knowledge is intrinsically connected to power in the sense that the former is a manifestation and exercise of the latter. When transferred to the current idea of the production of valid knowledge, it exposes the colossal influence of eurocentrism and western epistemologies. While western theories have contributed immensely to human knowledge, their dominance raises critical questions about inclusivity, representation, and the universality of knowledge. Understanding the Western dominance The dominance of Western theories in academia can be traced back to colonial history. The p...
Read more

Real Estate Crisis: Is India Facing A Housing Bubble?

-
Image
Introduction In recent years, the Indian real estate market has been the subject of much debate and speculation. Some experts have raised concerns about the possibility of a bubble, citing factors such as rapid price appreciation, high levels of unsold inventory, and a slowdown in sales. Home prices in almost all large Indian cities are unaffordable. In cities like Mumbai and Gurgaon, buying a home demands decades of savings.  In fact, as The Times of India   reported on June 24, 2025, it would take 109 years of savings for the richest 5 percent of families in Mumbai to be able to buy a home to live in. In Gurgaon it would take 64 years. For Bengaluru and Delhi, the figure was at 36 years and 35 years respectively. Now, these are average numbers, and like all average numbers they hide more than they reveal. Nonetheless, even if it would take half the number of years, the message is simple: Home prices in Indian cities have reached extremely high levels. Why Bubble migh...
Read more

Trump’s “Liberation Day” Tariffs: What Happened, What’s Next, and Why the World is Watching

-
Image
Introduction: The Bold Trade Gamble On April 2, 2025 , former U.S. President Donald Trump , currently running for re-election, declared a bold new economic policy titled “Liberation Day.” It marked the announcement of a massive tariff plan that aimed to reshape the U.S. trade landscape and reduce America's dependence on foreign goods. Here’s what he proposed: ·         A 10% universal tariff on all imports into the U.S. ·         Additional country-specific tariffs : o    China: Up to 60% more , making total duties up to 145% on some goods o    India: +27% o    Japan, Germany, and others: Tariffs ranging from 11% to 50% Trump framed this as a “second American Revolution” —claiming it would bring manufacturing back to U.S. soil, revive American jobs, and end what he calls “economic dependency” on China. Immediate Reactions (April 2–4) 🌍 Global Financial Shock Th...
Read more