RBI’s ₹1.5 trillion booster package: A critical analysis on the impact over Indian Economy
On 28th of January, 2025 the
prime-time business column of the Business Standard read as follows- “RBI to inject 1.5 trillion dollars into the
economy. Markets rebound and the road ahead”. As students of economics,
finance and enthusiasts of international relations; we found this as an
opportunity to apply the theoretical knowledge acquired so far and apply them
in this situation. Through this article, we aim to present a detailed and critical
analysis of this phenomenon of liquidity injection and its impact on the
world's fastest growing economy - India.
RBI’s Liquidity Injection Phenomenon - The 4 W's
Using the 4 W's framework we can gain an in-depth
understanding on the what, when, why and how of this move as under:
The WHATs-
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has announced special
measures to improve liquidity conditions
in the banking system.It is expected that ₹1.5
trillion (approx. $18 bn) would be injected in the system. This comes in
connection with the ‘pro-people and pro-developmental stance’ of the government
ahead of the monetary policy meeting with RBI.
As of Q-3 2024-25, our systemic liquidity registered a
deficit of ₹1.2 trillion. This was
mainly due to excess tax outflows along with depletion of forex
reserves.Additionally, commercial banks also borrowed ₹1.4 trillion daily from
the RBI’s repo window. This posed several constraints in systematic liquidity.
Furthermore, India’s current
account deficit stood at 1.2% of GDP, Q2, FY25. Also, dependence on foreign
capital for investment and energy requirements makes it vulnerable to external
shocks. Hence, RBI aims to inject liquidity in the economy at a rate of 6.75% which is higher than the existing short term lending rate (repo rate) at 6.5%.
Doing this will not only ease liquidity constraints but
also stabilize the short term shocks
in the markets.
The WHENs-
The RBI announced this policy when the liquidity gap
increased the burden on manufacturing, real estate and infrastructure sectors
as they are credit intensive. Due to liquidity constraints, banks may adopt a
stringent ‘selective credit control
policy’. Thus, due to higher interest rates and fund constraints, economic
explosion will experience a break. Through this booster (December
2024-January 2025) the RBI ensures that banks can continue
lending at reasonable interest rates and prevent credit slowdowns. This is the
second time, RBI is infusing liquidity in such huge amounts after December
2023.
On 3rd December, 2023, the RBI began this exercise by reducing Cash Reserve Ratio
(CRR) from
4.5% to 4%. After
that, the following measures were implemented:
● RBI
injected ₹20,000 crore into the system
through open market operations by lowering
the 10-year bond yield from 7.25% to 7.15%.
● After
that, it reduced the 3-month Treasury
Bill yield from 6.75% to 6.50%. This injected ₹10,000 crores into the
economy.
● To
keep the 10-year bond yield steady at a rate of 7.05%; RBI bought foreign currency reserves to stabilize the rupee.
● RBI
extended the long-term Marginal Standing
Facility (MSF); causing the 6-month
Treasury Bill yield to drop from 6.60% to 6.45%.
● Lastly,
Sensex rose 2-3% over December,2023.
owing to a positive market sentiment.
The WHYs-
The underlying cause behind this move are highlighted as
under:
Liquidity tightening to curb inflation
The CPI inflation
rose to 5.7% YoY in December 2023 against the 4% target rate. Additionally,
the prices of food items and staples rose at a higher rate than other goods of
the basket. While the similar step taken by RBI in December 2023 led to
tightening liquidity, further injection avoids such situations. Keeping the ever-increasing
GDP Growth rate curve of India, liquidity injection may enable us to attain the
projected rate of 6.5% (Q3, FY25)
Addressing the ‘liquidity gap’
Liquidity gap occurs when the rate of outflows exceeds the
rate of subsequent inflows. In December 2024, it was reported that India sold
forex reserves amounting to a whopping $50
billions. To the contrary, private capex on developmental projects remains
sluggish. This is primarily due to higher borrowing costs and tighter
short-term interest rates for developmental projects by the private sector.
However, credit growth to industry started rebounding and stood at 8.3% YoY as of December 2024.
Addressing securities market volatility
Capital outflows and rising U.S. Fed rates created
liquidity constraints. This not only created liquidity stress but also blocked
smooth credit flow. 10-year G-Sec yields
surged to 7.25% in December 2024 (vs. 7.1% in December 2023). This
increased the borrowing costs. Thus, RBI aims to ease pressure ahead of FY25
borrowing calendar. Not only that,
liquidity injection is also important to offset dollar sales given that $1=₹ 87.23 already.
Positive impact on investment vehicles
When RBI injects liquidity through short term interest
rates, the borrowing costs reduces. Due to this, INVITS (infrastructure
investment funds) that operate on a debt-equity mix are able to pool in more
funds, thus, increasing profitability. Additionally, this will lead to yield
compression. In a scenario of lower yield rates, investors will prefer
stability over price. This will indirectly
increase the demand for INVITS instruments, leading to their price hikes.
As mentioned above, INVITS operate on a debt-equity
mix, hence the impact on debt and equity remains similar.
Leverage higher yields on investment
vehicles
A point to be noted, that, during the recent liquidity
injection exercise in 2023, the returns of popular
InVITS like IndiGrid, IRB Infrastructure Trusts stood at 8-10%. Thus, another liquidity
injection may lead to another similar YoY return to the investors, given the
fact that green finance initiatives have surged the capital base of IndiGrid by around 50%. Furthermore,
energy stocks like TATA POWER showed an impressive CAGR of 23.4%. The demand
for green bonds also rose post liquidity injection.
The HOWs:
The multi-pronged approach to manage liquidity involves three instruments - CRR, OMO and 56
days VRR. The three major steps would be as under:
1. Open market operations: By purchasing
G-Secs, RBI aims to pump ₹60,000 crores into the economy. It will be done in 3
phases i.e. 30th January, 13th February and 20th February,2025 worth ₹20,000
crores each.This will ease borrowing costs and create a positive investor
sentiment.
2. Variable Rate Repo (VRR) auction: On
7th February, 2025. The RBI aims to conduct a 56-day VRR auction of
₹50,000 crores. The 56-day period is selected to give banks greater lending
flexibility. By conducting this VRR auction, the RBI aims to stabilize
overnight money market rates and attain economic stability.
3. Dollar-rupee swap auction: On January
31, the RBI will hold a $5 billion USD/INR buy/sell swap auction for a duration
of 6 months. The cut-off will be
determined based on the multi-pricing premium auction strategy.
Impacts of this policy through the STEEP lens:
The three phased liquidity injection policy of ₹1.5
trillion (approximately $18 billion) by RBI reflects the pro-developmental and proactive stance of India. Through STEEP
Analysis, we aim to underline the potential impacts across the entire economy.
1. Social Impact:
Increased liquidity could lower borrowing costs for
businesses and households. Financial inclusion can gain momentum through
increased channeling of funds to MSMEs. Due to increased EPFO enrollments by
around 1.2 million, we can also
expect the rapid job creation in the formal sector in the coming months.
Increased liquidity may broaden urban-centric credit flow (currently, 65% of total). This would fuel the
rural-urban divide; as well as the ‘middle
class trap’.
2. Technological Impact:
Increased credit access may accelerate digital
transformation and scale innovation. Sectors like fintech, e-commerce, and
green energy have immense potential to harness. However, this can give rise to ‘zombie firms’ whose contribution is
nil towards economic development. Such firms are able to cover only their
interest payments but not their entire costs of debt financing. As of December
2024, there are 600 such firms in India, which is a concern.
3. Economic Impact:
In the short run, liquidity injection can stabilize bond
markets,ease credit crunches and support government borrowing. However, if this
liquidity is not absorbed productively, the credit intensive sectors may
develop asset bubbles in the long run. Also, the rupee can depreciate yet
further with imports becoming costlier due to cost push inflation.
Following the announcement of liquidity injection on
January 28, 2025;
● Nifty 50 rose 4% in the following
week.
● Financial
sectors (e.g., HDFC Bank, ICICI) are expecting
higher benefits from lower borrowing costs.
● State's
borrowing costs are expected to reduce
by 20-30 bps.
● The
mid-cap stocks along with underperformed
large-caps surged by 8% due to increased risk appetite.
● Lastly,
enhanced liquidity gives birth to speculative trading.Thus, India’s VIX Volatility Index spiked to 19.55 points
following the announcement.
4. Environmental
Impact:
If the increased liquidity is properly channelized towards
developing the green infrastructure (renewable energy, EVs), India can be a
step closer towards its Net Zero Carbon
Emission Goals, 2030. Conversely, indiscriminate industrialization may
undermine sustainability.
5. Political
Impact:
The government's aim to maintain a loose monetary policy is
somewhat deviated from the RBI's inflation-tightened policies.
The government in collaboration with the Monetary Policy
Committee should also try to align this liquidity injection with our National Infrastructure Pipeline
project. Furthermore,
Private-Public-Partnership
(PPP) models may be used to promote inclusivity and increase our business
competitiveness.
The Way Forward
Despite having an impressive growth rate of 8.2% last
quarter, India suffers from import
dependency, export fluctuations, insufficient FDI flows and an
ever-depreciating currency. India's efforts for financial engineering is
not new given that RBI introduced a similar
Booster package of over ₹1.1 trillion in 2023 powered by MSF and SLF
facilities. However, the potential pitfalls experienced that time can be
avoided if we use our forex reserves
judiciously, prioritise lending to MSMEs, agriculture and incentivize exports
in the IT Sector.This will not only lead to improved logistics efficiency
but also level up our existing supply chain. Lastly, liquidity injection is an
important tool to foster economic stability and growth while keeping in mind
the threshold inflation band of 2-6%.
Reference:
Rajan Raghuram, Acharya V. (2021-23), “Liquidity, liquidity everywhere, not a drop to use”
https://www.business-standard.com/article/finance/as-liquidity-tightens-rbi-injects-rs-1-trn-largest-inf
usion-in-4-years-123031700981_1.html
https://m.economictimes.com/news/economy/finance/liquidity-push-rbi-readies-1-5-lakh-crore-injecti
on/articleshow/117611950.cms
https://indianexpress.com/article/business/rbi-announces-5-bn-forex-swap-omos-and-vrr-to-inject-liqu
idity-9802575/
https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1814774
Kalimpali M, et al. (2019) “Does Liquidity Infusion Impact Financial Stability? Evidence from Fed’s
Corporate Bond Purchases”
-By, Soham Sen and Nidhi Attri
M.Com, 1st Year.
Comments
Post a Comment